Skip to content
Thomson Reuters
Law

Factbox: German court rules in favor of city bans on diesel cars

Reuters Staff

27 Feb 2018

BERLIN (Reuters) – A top German court ruled on Tuesday in favor of allowing major cities to ban heavily polluting diesel cars, a move likely to hit the value of 12 million vehicles in Europe’s largest car market and force carmakers to pay for costly modifications.

Cars are pictured near Germany’s federal administrative court in Leipzig, Germany, February 27, 2018. REUTERS/Fabrizio Bensch 

Analysts have said the ruling of the Leipzig court will be crucial in shaping demand across Europe where diesel-car sales have been declining for months on the back of a regulatory backlash and amid signs of widespread rigging of emission tests among carmakers.

1. WHAT WAS AT STAKE?

Germany’s DUH environmental lobby sued the regional capitals of Stuttgart and Duesseldorf to force them to comply with European Union air pollution limits they have violated for years.

The two associated German states appealed against the rulings, leaving the federal administrative court in Leipzig to decide whether city bans for diesel cars are legal. Diesel-vehicle emissions cause respiratory problems and have been linked to premature deaths.

2. HOW MANY CARS COULD BE AFFECTED?

Any driving bans would probably affect vehicles equipped with Euro-5 emissions-control technology and older models. Of the 15 million diesel cars on Germany’s roads last year, about 2.7 million were fitted with the latest Euro-6 standard, which has applied to all new cars sold since September 2015, according to the KBA motor vehicle watchdog.

3. HOW FAST COULD DRIVING BANS BE LAUNCHED?

Affected cities would need at least six months to redraw their anti-pollution strategies before any bans could take effect, legal experts have said. Germany’s ADAC motorist club does not even expect bans to be launched before the end of the year. Prior to any implementation, German lawmakers will likely be asked to overhaul nationwide road traffic regulations.

4. WHAT WOULD BE THE IMPLICATIONS?

Any restriction will likely accelerate the drop in demand from consumers already worried about resale values and possible recalls. Carmakers have been adapting their model lineups to make up for consumers’ sudden shift to gasoline vehicles. Traffic bans in Europe’s biggest auto market would likely influence policies across the region.

Reporting by Andreas Cremer; Editing by Keith Weir
Our Standards:The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.
London, other cities call for new petrol and diesel car ban to start earlier INTERVIEW-Lawmaker urges more U.S. support for businesses that do good Big Brother facial recognition by police challenged in Britain Brazil overhauls decades-old mining law, eyeing investment Award-winning smart drones to take on illegal fishing Main customer of Arizona coal plant goes green, ignoring Interior Department US government faces legal action over not addressing racially divided housing Colombia lawmakers ask Americas rights body to protect hundreds of at-risk activists Australia aims to be global leader with strong anti-slavery law in 2018 Trinidad and Tobago court says laws barring gay sex are unconstitutional